|
Acceptances:
Mirk83 2008:
PROFILE: Type of Undergrad: Maths degree in a good Italian university (and student of its honor college) Undergrad GPA: 3.0/3.0 Type of Grad: Maths degree (student of a program jointly organized with the best scientific research center of the country, that is also a doctoral school) and attending a one year master in economics Grad GPA: 3.0/3.0 GRE: 700 V, 800 Q, 5.0 AWA Math Courses: everything you can think about (seriously, in five year of Maths I've attended at least 30-40 Maths courses, some of which at PhD level) Econ Courses: very very few courses, and just during this year: the basic Micro, Macro and Econometrics (at the level of MWG, Blanchard-Fisher, Hayashi - but of course not all the topics) Other Courses: a bit of physics and informatics down the road and a bit of neurobiology (my master thesis was about building a kinetic model for a class of ion channels!) Letters of Recommendation: my weak point. A good, but maybe a bit standard, letter from my thesis advisor, who is a very well known mathematician (who knows me well, since the thesis was partly of research). A very good letter from an economist who taught at the honor college I was in but with whom I took just that small course, a few years ago. And a letter from another well known mathematician whose course I attended during an international summer school - I really have no idea of what he could have written. Research Experience: just for the thesis - and in maths applied to neurobiology... Teaching Experience: none Research Interests: behavioural models, game theory; but my interests are now moving a bit more towards Macro topics SOP: just tried to explain why I have been moving from Pure Maths to Applied Maths and then from applications to biology to economics... RESULTS: Acceptances: Caltech ($$), LSE (MRes/Phd track 1) ($$), Oxford MPhil (?) Waitlists: NYU Rejections: Chicago, MIT What would you have done differently? Hard to say. Given my erratic background and the not-so-strong LORs, I think I have calibrated well the applications (my estimate was to have good possibilities from the bottom of the top ten - just like NYU and LSE - downward). Of course I could have waited one more year, finished the economics master in order to use the grades as an additional signal and obtained better LORs... but I'm already 24 and I have already two masters, so I think it's time to move as quickly as possible towards real research.
Accepts: Acceptances: Caltech ($$), LSE (MRes/Phd track 1) ($$), Oxford MPhil (?)
Rejects:
Waitlists:
canecon 2008:
School: UBC Major: Econ (Hons) GPA: 3.5 (3.98 upper-econ, 3.98 math (excluding failed calc 1)) GRE: 800q 480v 5.0 AWA (despite the awful verbal I am native English speaker / English background) Courses: Econ:Hon micro/macro I (A+'s) Game Theory (Hon) A, Hon Macro II A+, + intro metrics I/II (A+) + lots electives (mostly A+) Math: Calc 1 (F first time then A), Calc 2, linear, multivariable, ODE's, probability(calc based), intro proof A+'s intro analysis A Now Taking: Honours Thesis, Advanced Macro, Econometrics Research: Thesis letter of recommendation: 3 Assistant Profs, I say mediocre since I had no special relationship, just took their classes. SOP: Pretty bad I think... that might just be me - but I didn't have any professors read it since I thought it was crappy (very bad reason I know - I expect I might have had spelling/grammar errors as well ). But I guess for Master's it doesn't matter that much. Interests: Macro, Int trade/finance/development. Schools: Decided to apply only for Masters: LSE, UCL, Oxford, Cambridge, Warwick, UPF, UBC, Toronto, Queens, UWO, Stockholm. My Concerns: First year really sucked, second year was average. Only have 1.5 years of good grades. RESULTS: Acceptances: LSE Msc (1 year, Res), UCL MSc, Warwick MSc, Oxford M.Phil (??), UPF MSc($$), Queen's MA ($$), Toronto Doc. Stream MA ($$), UBC MA ($$), UWO MA ($$), Still Waiting: Cambridge M.Phil (B), Stockholm University MSc (Research) Rejections: None (yet) What would you have done differently? -known that I was going to go for grad school (in econ) earlier -started preparing to apply in the summer, or early sept, or early october. (didnt start applications earlier because very math-packed semester. No time in summer though b/c courses and GRE - basically crammed all the math I needed in last 8 mths I would have grades for). -Looked into scholarship opportunities for study in UK (many seem to have deadlines around sept/oct. ) I started looking the next february/march. -Basically I did what I could. Maybe should have applied to some PhD straight away, but still not sure what I want to do and I didn't really have time to put together good apps. Accepts: Acceptances: LSE Msc (1 year, Res), UCL MSc, Warwick MSc, Oxford M.Phil (??), UPF MSc($$), Queen's MA ($$), Toronto Doc. Stream MA ($$), UBC MA ($$), UWO MA ($$),
Still
Rejects:
Waitlists: Waiting: Cambridge M.Phil (B), Stockholm University MSc (Research)
elcapitano 2008:
GRE: 800Q 720V 4.5AW(doh) (2nd Attempt) Undergrad: Good but not brilliant research university High 1st Class Degree All Maths and Econ Courses 1st in 12 of 14 including all the maths courses. Graduated 2nd in class. Math: All that I was allowed to take SOP: Probably weak Experience: Two years in government Interests: Growth, Development, Trade Applied: Brown, Columbia, Harvard, Oxford (MPhil), NYU, UBC (MA) Results: Accepted - UBC ($$), Oxford ($?) Rejected - Brown, Columbia, Harvard, NYU What would you have done differently? I would've realised that UK undergrad and some work experience is not sufficient to get into a top US program. Having realised this I also would've applied to Cambridge for their MPhil and probably LSE and not bothered applying for US programs this time round. However, i'm still pretty happy.
Accepts: Accepted - UBC ($$), Oxford ($?)
Rejects: Rejected - Brown, Columbia, Harvard, NYU
Waitlists:
|
|
Waitlists:
canadamike 2008:
PROFILE: Type of Undergrad: BA Economics (Honours) from a top Canadian School (though not top in Economics) Undergrad GPA: With 2 terms left, almost a 3.3 but if you look beyond first year it goes up to over 3.8 GRE: 790Q, 600V, 5.0AWA Math Courses: Calculus 1, Algebra 1, and I failed Linear Algebra in first year Econ Courses (undergrad-level): All the core courses plus advanced Econometrics and international economics courses (trade, finance, institutions). 83% Average overall Other Courses: Philosophy minor Letters of Recommendation: 2 Econ (1 Assistant Prof, 1 Lecturer) and for Oxford I got a 2nd Assistant Prof Research Interests: Trade theory, sports economics SOP: Done and Done Concerns: Poor first year (poor is an understatement); only a 780verall; worried my bad first year performance will outshine my grades since Applying to: LSE, Oxford, UCL, Warwick, Nottingham, Bristol, York RESULTS: Acceptances: York (UK), Nottingham, Warwick Rejections: LSE Waiting: Bristol, UCL, Oxford
Accepts: Acceptances: York (UK), Nottingham, Warwick
Rejects:
Waitlists: Waiting: Bristol, UCL, Oxford
|